Following #12568
In issue #9357, when inserting an element larger than 1GB, we currently
store it in a plain node instead of a listpack.
Presently, when we insert an element that exceeds the maximum size of a
packed node, it cannot be accommodated in any other nodes, thus ending
up isolated like a large element.
I.e. it's a node with only one element, but it's listpack encoded rather
than a plain buffer.
This PR lowers the threshold for considering an element as 'large' from
1GB to the maximum size of a node.
While this change doesn't completely resolve the bug mentioned in the
previous PR, it does mitigate its potential impact.
As a result of this change, we can now only use LSET to replace an
element with another element that falls below the maximum size
threshold.
In the worst-case scenario, with a fill of -5, the largest packed node
we can create is 2GB (32k * 64k):
* 32k: The smallest element in a listpack is 2 bytes, which allows us to
store up to 32k elements.
* 64k: This is the maximum size for a single quicklist node.
## Others
To fully fix#9357, we need more work, as discussed in #12568, when we
insert an element into a quicklistNode, it may be created in a new node,
put into another node, or merged, and we can't correctly delete the node
that was supposed to be deleted.
I'm not sure it's worth it, since it involves a lot of modifications.
We forgot to call quicklistSetOptions after createQuicklistObject,
in the sort store scenario, we will create a quicklist with default
fill or compress options.
This PR adds fill and depth parameters to createQuicklistObject to
specify that options need to be set after creating a quicklist.
This closes#12871.
release notes:
> Fix lists created by SORT STORE to respect list compression and
packing configs.
Improve memory efficiency of list keys
## Description of the feature
The new listpack encoding uses the old `list-max-listpack-size` config
to perform the conversion, which we can think it of as a node inside a
quicklist, but without 80 bytes overhead (internal fragmentation included)
of quicklist and quicklistNode structs.
For example, a list key with 5 items of 10 chars each, now takes 128 bytes
instead of 208 it used to take.
## Conversion rules
* Convert listpack to quicklist
When the listpack length or size reaches the `list-max-listpack-size` limit,
it will be converted to a quicklist.
* Convert quicklist to listpack
When a quicklist has only one node, and its length or size is reduced to half
of the `list-max-listpack-size` limit, it will be converted to a listpack.
This is done to avoid frequent conversions when we add or remove at the bounding size or length.
## Interface changes
1. add list entry param to listTypeSetIteratorDirection
When list encoding is listpack, `listTypeIterator->lpi` points to the next entry of current entry,
so when changing the direction, we need to use the current node (listTypeEntry->p) to
update `listTypeIterator->lpi` to the next node in the reverse direction.
## Benchmark
### Listpack VS Quicklist with one node
* LPUSH - roughly 0.3% improvement
* LRANGE - roughly 13% improvement
### Both are quicklist
* LRANGE - roughly 3% improvement
* LRANGE without pipeline - roughly 3% improvement
From the benchmark, as we can see from the results
1. When list is quicklist encoding, LRANGE improves performance by <5%.
2. When list is listpack encoding, LRANGE improves performance by ~13%,
the main enhancement is brought by `addListListpackRangeReply()`.
## Memory usage
1M lists(key:0~key:1000000) with 5 items of 10 chars ("hellohello") each.
shows memory usage down by 35.49%, from 214MB to 138MB.
## Note
1. Add conversion callback to support doing some work before conversion
Since the quicklist iterator decompresses the current node when it is released, we can
no longer decompress the quicklist after we convert the list.
This PR mainly deals with 2 crashes introduced in #9357,
and fix the QUICKLIST-PACKED-THRESHOLD mess in external test mode.
1. Fix crash due to deleting an entry from a compress quicklistNode
When inserting a large element, we need to create a new quicklistNode first,
and then delete its previous element, if the node where the deleted element is
located is compressed, it will cause a crash.
Now add `dont_compress` to quicklistNode, if we want to use a quicklistNode
after some operation, we can use this flag like following:
```c
node->dont_compress = 1; /* Prevent to be compressed */
some_operation(node); /* This operation might try to compress this node */
some_other_operation(node); /* We can use this node without decompress it */
node->dont_compress = 0; /* Re-able compression */
quicklistCompressNode(node);
```
Perhaps in the future, we could just disable the current entry from being
compressed during the iterator loop, but that would require more work.
2. Fix crash due to wrongly split quicklist
before #9357, the offset param of _quicklistSplitNode() will not negative.
For now, when offset is negative, the split extent will be wrong.
following example:
```c
int orig_start = after ? offset + 1 : 0;
int orig_extent = after ? -1 : offset;
int new_start = after ? 0 : offset;
int new_extent = after ? offset + 1 : -1;
# offset: -2, after: 1, node->count: 2
# current wrong range: [-1,-1] [0,-1]
# correct range: [1,-1] [0, 1]
```
Because only `_quicklistInsert()` splits the quicklistNode and only
`quicklistInsertAfter()`, `quicklistInsertBefore()` call _quicklistInsert(),
so `quicklistReplaceEntry()` and `listTypeInsert()` might occur this crash.
But the iterator of `listTypeInsert()` is alway from head to tail(iter->offset is
always positive), so it is not affected.
The final conclusion is this crash only occur when we insert a large element
with negative index into a list, that affects `LSET` command and `RM_ListSet`
module api.
3. In external test mode, we need to restore quicklist packed threshold after
when the end of test.
4. Show `node->count` in quicklistRepr().
5. Add new tcl proc `config_get_set` to support restoring config in tests.
add a comment to `container` in `quicklist.h`.
Because `PLAIN` and `PACKED` are not as easy to understand as `NONE`
and `LISTPACK` and we don't have a detailed comment on it.
Co-authored-by: Oran Agra <oran@redislabs.com>
fix an unclear comment quicklist container formats to quicklist node container formats
Add a comment to 'zi' in quicklistIter (Where it first appeared)
Why do I add a comment to zi:
Because it is not a variable name with a clear meaning, and its name seems to be from the deprecated ziplist.
Recent PRs have introduced some failures, this commit
try to fix these CI failures. Here are the changes:
1. Enable debug-command in sentinel test.
```
Master reboot in very short time: ERR DEBUG command not allowed. If the
enable-debug-command option is set to "local", you can run it from a
local connection, otherwise you need to set this option in the
configuration file, and then restart the server.
```
2. Enable protected-config in sentinel test.
```
SDOWN is triggered by misconfigured instance replying with errors: ERR
CONFIG SET failed (possibly related to argument 'dir') - can't set
protected config
```
3. Enable debug-command in cluster test.
```
Verify slaves consistency: ERR DEBUG command not allowed. If the
enable-debug-command option is set to "local", you can run it from a
local connection, otherwise you need to set this option in the
configuration file, and then restart the server.
```
4. quicklist fill should be signed int.
The reason for the modification is to eliminate the warning.
Modify `int fill: QL_FILL_BITS` to `signed int fill: QL_FILL_BITS`
The first three were introduced at #9920 (same issue).
And the last one was introduced at #9962.
1. Local variable 's' hides a parameter of the same name.
```
int anetTcpAccept(char *err, int s, char *ip, size_t ip_len, int *port) {
if ((fd = anetGenericAccept(err,s,(struct sockaddr*)&sa,&salen)) == ANET_ERR){}
}
```
Change the parameter name from `s` to `serversock`,
also unified with the header file definition.
2. Comparison is always false because i <= 48.
```
for (i = 0; i < DICT_STATS_VECTLEN-1; i++) { // i < 49
(i == DICT_STATS_VECTLEN-1)?">= ":"", // i == 49
}
```
`i == DICT_STATS_VECTLEN-1` always result false, it is a dead code.
3. Empty block without comment.
`else if (!strcasecmp(opt,"ch")) {}`, add a comment to avoid warnings.
4. Bit field fill of type int should have explicitly unsigned integral, explicitly signed integral, or enumeration type.
Modify `int fill: QL_FILL_BITS;` to `unsigned int fill: QL_FILL_BITS;`
5. The result of this call to reconnectingRedisCommand is not checked for null, but 80% of calls to reconnectingRedisCommand check for null.
Just a cleanup job like others.
This pr is following #9779 .
## Describe of feature
Now when we turn on the `list-compress-depth` configuration, the list will compress
the ziplist between `[list-compress-depth, -list-compress-depth]`.
When we need to use the compressed data, we will first decompress it, then use it,
and finally compress it again.
It's controlled by `quicklistNode->recompress`, which is designed to avoid the need to
re-traverse the entire quicklist for compression after each decompression, we only need
to recompress the quicklsitNode being used.
In order to ensure the correctness of recompressing, we should normally let
quicklistDecompressNodeForUse and quicklistCompress appear in pairs, otherwise,
it may lead to the head and tail being compressed or the middle ziplist not being
compressed correctly, which is exactly the problem this pr needs to solve.
## Solution
1. Reset `quicklistIter` after insert and replace.
The quicklist node will be compressed in `quicklistInsertAfter`, `quicklistInsertBefore`,
`quicklistReplaceAtIndex`, so we can safely reset the quicklistIter to avoid it being used again
2. `quicklistIndex` will return an iterator that can be used to recompress the current node after use.
## Test
1. In the `Stress Tester for #3343-Similar Errors` test, when the server crashes or when
`valgrind` or `asan` error is detected, print violating commands.
2. Add a crash test due to wrongly recompressing after `lrem`.
3. Remove `insert before with 0 elements` and `insert after with 0 elements`,
Now we forbid any operation on an NULL quicklistIter.
Part three of implementing #8702, following #8887 and #9366 .
## Description of the feature
1. Replace the ziplist container of quicklist with listpack.
2. Convert existing quicklist ziplists on RDB loading time. an O(n) operation.
## Interface changes
1. New `list-max-listpack-size` config is an alias for `list-max-ziplist-size`.
2. Replace `debug ziplist` command with `debug listpack`.
## Internal changes
1. Add `lpMerge` to merge two listpacks . (same as `ziplistMerge`)
2. Add `lpRepr` to print info of listpack which is used in debugCommand and `quicklistRepr`. (same as `ziplistRepr`)
3. Replace `QUICKLIST_NODE_CONTAINER_ZIPLIST` with `QUICKLIST_NODE_CONTAINER_PACKED`(following #9357 ).
It represent that a quicklistNode is a packed node, as opposed to a plain node.
4. Remove `createZiplistObject` method, which is never used.
5. Calculate listpack entry size using overhead overestimation in `quicklistAllowInsert`.
We prefer an overestimation, which would at worse lead to a few bytes below the lowest limit of 4k.
## Improvements
1. Calling `lpShrinkToFit` after converting Ziplist to listpack, which was missed at #9366.
2. Optimize `quicklistAppendPlainNode` to avoid memcpy data.
## Bugfix
1. Fix crash in `quicklistRepr` when ziplist is compressed, introduced from #9366.
## Test
1. Add unittest for `lpMerge`.
2. Modify the old quicklist ziplist corrupt dump test.
Co-authored-by: Oran Agra <oran@redislabs.com>
Redis lists are stored in quicklist, which is currently a linked list of ziplists.
Ziplists are limited to storing elements no larger than 4GB, so when bigger
items are added they're getting truncated.
This PR changes quicklists so that they're capable of storing large items
in quicklist nodes that are plain string buffers rather than ziplist.
As part of the PR there were few other changes in redis:
1. new DEBUG sub-commands:
- QUICKLIST-PACKED-THRESHOLD - set the threshold of for the node type to
be plan or ziplist. default (1GB)
- QUICKLIST <key> - Shows low level info about the quicklist encoding of <key>
2. rdb format change:
- A new type was added - RDB_TYPE_LIST_QUICKLIST_2 .
- container type (packed / plain) was added to the beginning of the rdb object
(before the actual node list).
3. testing:
- Tests that requires over 100MB will be by default skipped. a new flag was
added to 'runtest' to run the large memory tests (not used by default)
Co-authored-by: sundb <sundbcn@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Oran Agra <oran@redislabs.com>
List functions operating on elements by index:
* RM_ListGet
* RM_ListSet
* RM_ListInsert
* RM_ListDelete
Iteration is done using a simple for loop over indices.
The index based functions use an internal iterator as an optimization.
This is explained in the docs:
```
* Many of the list functions access elements by index. Since a list is in
* essence a doubly-linked list, accessing elements by index is generally an
* O(N) operation. However, if elements are accessed sequentially or with
* indices close together, the functions are optimized to seek the index from
* the previous index, rather than seeking from the ends of the list.
*
* This enables iteration to be done efficiently using a simple for loop:
*
* long n = RM_ValueLength(key);
* for (long i = 0; i < n; i++) {
* RedisModuleString *elem = RedisModule_ListGet(key, i);
* // Do stuff...
* }
```
1. Add `redis-server test all` support to run all tests.
2. Add redis test to daily ci.
3. Add `--accurate` option to run slow tests for more iterations (so that
by default we run less cycles (shorter time, and less prints).
4. Move dict benchmark to REDIS_TEST.
5. fix some leaks in tests
6. make quicklist tests run on a specific fill set of options rather than huge ranges
7. move some prints in quicklist test outside their loops to reduce prints
8. removing sds.h from dict.c since it is now used in both redis-server and
redis-cli (uses hiredis sds)
When active defrag kicks in and finds a big list, it will create a bookmark to
a node so that it is able to resume iteration from that node later.
The quicklist manages that bookmark, and updates it in case that node is deleted.
This will increase memory usage only on lists of over 1000 (see
active-defrag-max-scan-fields) quicklist nodes (1000 ziplists, not 1000 items)
by 16 bytes.
In 32 bit build, this change reduces the maximum effective config of
list-compress-depth and list-max-ziplist-size (from 32767 to 8191)
Let user set how many nodes to *not* compress.
We can specify a compression "depth" of how many nodes
to leave uncompressed on each end of the quicklist.
Depth 0 = disable compression.
Depth 1 = only leave head/tail uncompressed.
- (read as: "skip 1 node on each end of the list before compressing")
Depth 2 = leave head, head->next, tail->prev, tail uncompressed.
- ("skip 2 nodes on each end of the list before compressing")
Depth 3 = Depth 2 + head->next->next + tail->prev->prev
- ("skip 3 nodes...")
etc.
This also:
- updates RDB storage to use native quicklist compression (if node is
already compressed) instead of uncompressing, generating the RDB string,
then re-compressing the quicklist node.
- internalizes the "fill" parameter for the quicklist so we don't
need to pass it to _every_ function. Now it's just a property of
the list.
- allows a runtime-configurable compression option, so we can
expose a compresion parameter in the configuration file if people
want to trade slight request-per-second performance for up to 90%+
memory savings in some situations.
- updates the quicklist tests to do multiple passes: 200k+ tests now.
Fill factor now has two options:
- negative (1-5) for size-based ziplist filling
- positive for length-based ziplist filling with implicit size cap.
Negative offsets define ziplist size limits of:
-1: 4k
-2: 8k
-3: 16k
-4: 32k
-5: 64k
Positive offsets now automatically limit their max size to 8k. Any
elements larger than 8k will be in individual nodes.
Positive ziplist fill factors will keep adding elements
to a ziplist until one of:
- ziplist has FILL number of elements
- or -
- ziplist grows above our ziplist max size (currently 8k)
When using positive fill factors, if you insert a large
element (over 8k), that element will automatically allocate
an individual quicklist node with one element and no other elements will be
in the same ziplist inside that quicklist node.
When using negative fill factors, elements up to the size
limit can be added to one quicklist node. If an element
is added larger than the max ziplist size, that element
will be allocated an individual ziplist in a new quicklist node.
Tests also updated to start testing at fill factor -5.
This replaces individual ziplist vs. linkedlist representations
for Redis list operations.
Big thanks for all the reviews and feedback from everybody in
https://github.com/antirez/redis/pull/2143